Each month, The Junior Senator (find his blog HERE) and I will collaborate on our own Comic Writer Power Rankings for the prior month. Welcome to the first installment! While he and I agree on a great many things (as the Emperor would say), there are some differences of opinion and, while we will collaborate monthly on the rankings, we’ll include our distinctive comments! In the process of building the list, we’re taking into account sales data as well. Some of these dudes move a lot of comics!
And here … we … go.
Honorable Mentions
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: Brian Wood, whose new ʺX-Womenʺ series is off to a good start, even if this month’s Battle of the Atom tie-in was just average. And while I’m waiting for the trade, I continue to hear good things about his Star Wars on-going.
I SAY: Peter Tomasi who made the character Damien Wayne come to life in such a way that Morrison’s final stories featuring him had more emotional punch than they would have. Additionally, his Bane issue of the Forever Evil ʺpointsʺ was truly outstanding and illustrated what the New 52 should be.
TEN: Mike Allred
![MikeAllred](https://andtherecameaday.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/mikeallred.jpg?w=224&h=300)
TITLES: FF #12
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: FF (#124)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: Lee Allred deserves credit for picking up where Fraction left off on this title. It probably helps that he’s working with his brother doing the art, but the tone that made this such a fun, quirky title seems to have (so far) continued.
I SAY: There is no art that says ʺcomic bookʺ to me more than Allred’s. His writing is in line with that reaction. I eagerly await his Fraction-less take on FF, not that I haven’t enjoyed Fraction here. I have very much. If he’s been an influence thus far – and I believe that he has – we’re in for a treat.
NINE: Matt Fraction
![Matt Fraction](https://andtherecameaday.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/matt-fraction.jpg?w=266&h=300)
TITLES: Satellite Sam #3, Sex Criminals #1
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: Sex Criminals (#54) and Satellite Sam (#182)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: Two months ago, I might’ve called Fraction my favorite writer, with his work on Hawkeye, Fantastic Four, and FF, plus my reading his old run on Iron Man. Now? Sex Criminals was pretty good (a strange sentence to write), but I just haven’t gotten into Satellite Sam yet, and we were without any Hawkguy for the entire month.
I SAY: Hey, Hawkguy? Where be you? Fraction is terrific (and I am a sucker for his personal life being married to fellow scribe Kelly Sue deConnick) but I need MORE. NOW! The independent stuff … I am trying to get into it, but am waiting for The Junior Senator to say “do it.”
EIGHT: Greg Pak
TITLES: Batman/Superman #23.1 – Doomsday
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: Batman/Superman (#21)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: I only read two of DC’s 23.x issues–this and the Joker. This Doomsday issue was actually decent, and Pak deserves credit for what I think is shaping up to be a strong series.
I SAY: What Pak has done at Marvel is well documented and I am loving what he’s doing with Batman/Superman. It’s a compelling, if a bit confusing, take on the icons.
SEVEN: Brian K. Vaughn
TITLES: Saga #12
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: Saga (#26)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: Rare is the month when Saga isn’t the best comic I read. If it were up to me, of course, I’d have it nearer the top, but since my compatriot won’t read anything ʺindepedent,ʺ here we are. Still, issue #12 was really great, and as always I don’t think there’s a better blend of writing and art.
I SAY: I have to defer to The Junior Senator on this one… but the trades I’ve read of Saga are really, really good. I am trying!
SIX: Scott Snyder
TITLES: The Wake #4
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: The Wake (#88)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: Snyder will usually be much higher for me, but he took the month off of Batman. Still, The Wake has been very good, and I’m surprised at how much I continue to enjoy it, only because I wouldn’t normally consider ʺhorrorʺ to be my genre.
I SAY: Snyder is my number one guy right now. Who else can handle both Batman and Superman as well? Who else could get me into an ʺindependentʺ comic like The Wake? Answer: no one.
FIVE: Jason Aaron
TITLES: Thor #13, Wolverine and the X-Men #36
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: Thor (#25), Wolverine and the X-Men (#39)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: Aaron’s contribution to the Battle of the Atom event was nothing special, but the problems are mostly the same as with all the other writers in that event. Thor’s new arc, conveniently starring the same antagonist as the new movie, is off to a good start.
I SAY: I was underwhelmed by the latest arc of Wolverine and the X-Men, but Aaron’s been so consistently good, he deserves the recognition.
FOUR: Geoff Johns
TITLES: Forever Evil #1, Aquaman #23, Aquaman #23.2
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: Forever Evil (#1), Aquaman (#61, #159)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: I will try not to repeat this same comment every month, but I just don’t read much DC, and nothing from the Justice League family, including this new event. I enjoy getting the summaries from my compatriot every week though.
I SAY: In my mind Johns is about to leap higher… once we’re done with the Forever Evil ʺpointʺ issues and we’re deeper into Forever Evil and Justice League, we’ll see Johns change the DC Universe. Again. I might even forgive him for unmasking Nightwing.
THREE: Mark Waid
TITLES: Daredevil #31, Indestructible Hulk #13
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: Daredevil (#60) Hulk (#47)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: Waid writes the most consistently great comic (Daredevil) and another consistently good one (Hulk). I only wish he were writing more popular characters to get the recognition–and sales–he deserves. By quality alone, he should be in the top three every month.
I SAY: The only thing on our list keeping Waid at #3 – as far as I am concerned – is his numbers which are criminally low. No one knows more comic history than Waid and no one distills it better in his writing. To call his take on Daredevil “loving” is an understatement. He loved this character back to life after some terrible stories. He’s working similar magic on the Hulk.
TWO: Brian Michael Bendis
TITLES: All New X-Men #16, Battle of the Atom #1, Uncanny X-Men #12, Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man #27
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: All New X-Men (#12), Battle of the Atom (#4), Uncanny X-Men (#16), Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man (#81)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: If my problem with Hickman is that his stories are too big, Bendis is the opposite: he’s telling small stories (which is his strength), but trying to draw them out to big events. Battle of the Atom started out strong, but is already feeling a bit… padded.
I SAY: Bendis is wordy, no doubt. He can cram more words in a panel than anyone. He gives good events (bracketing Age of Ultron). This is a good event. Not great, but good enough for #2. And his creation of the Miles Morales Spider-Man from the Ultimate Universe has, surprisingly, been under the radar recently. It shouldn’t be.
ONE: Johnathan Hickman
TITLES: Infinity #2, Avengers #19, Infinity #3, Avengers #20, East of West #6
DIAMOND DISTRIBUTORS SALES DATA: Infinity (#2, #3), Avengers (#9, #17), New Avengers (#10), East of West (#77, #1 Trade Paperback)
THE JUNIOR SENATOR SAYS: Hickman is far from my favorite writer, but I’m starting to warm up to both Infinty and East of West. Plus, it’s hard to ignore those sales numbers.
I SAY: I will grant my friend the sales numbers here. They are what put Hickman over the top to the Number One position this month. My only caveat: I feel like a pretty smart guy (the stating of which ʺfactʺ probably betrays that I am not) and I don’t always understand Hickman. I think I like him a lot, though.
That’s if for this month! See you next time!